The US Department of Justice sues Visa, accusing it of illegally monopolizing the debit card market
楚一帆
发表于 2024-9-25 19:16:53
180
0
0
The US Department of Justice filed a lawsuit on Tuesday (September 24th) local time, accusing financial giant Visa of illegally monopolizing the debit card market and stifling peer competition, resulting in American consumers and businesses paying a large amount of additional fees.
The service fees charged by Visa far exceed what it should charge in the market competition. Merchants and banks pass on these costs to consumers, and this behavior almost affects the prices of all goods, "said US Attorney General Merrick Garland in a statement.
In the indictment submitted to the Federal Court in New York, the US Department of Justice stated that over 60% of debit cards in the United States are processed through Visa's network, and Visa can earn over $7 billion in transaction fees from these transactions.
In response to the allegations, Visa stated that they are "baseless" and stated that they will defend themselves in court.
The indictment details Visa's "charges"
This lawsuit is the latest in a series of antitrust lawsuits filed by the Biden administration. Earlier this year, the Department of Justice filed antitrust lawsuits against Ticketmaster and Apple, while Google lost last month in the Department of Justice's antitrust lawsuit.
In the lawsuit against Visa, the Department of Justice stated that Visa achieved its monopoly by incentivizing potential competitors to become partners, providing "generous" kickbacks, and threatening to charge punitive fees.
The Department of Justice also accuses Visa of signing exclusive agreements with merchants and banks, punishing customers who attempt to conduct transactions through other company systems.
Prior to Tuesday's lawsuit, the Department of Justice had filed a lawsuit against Visa in 2020, which blocked Visa's plan to acquire fintech company Plaid. The Department of Justice stated at the time that this transaction would enable Visa to "maintain its monopoly position and strong competitiveness in debit cards".
In addition to Visa, another major player in the US debit card industry, Mastercard, has also been subject to regulatory scrutiny. Last year, Mastercard reached a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission over its complaint of suppressing competitive payment networks.
Professor Douglas Ross from the University of Washington Law School believes that introducing more competition in the US debit card market may help lower transaction fees.
If we gain more competition in this field, the entire economy can save a lot of money cumulatively, but consumers may not directly notice this saved money, "Ross said." This does not mean that consumers are not harmed at present. A penny here, a penny there, and millions of transactions add up to a large sum of money
Rebecca Haw Allensworth, a professor at Vanderbilt Law School in Nashville, Tennessee, stated that the outcome of this lawsuit will still depend on how Visa defends itself.
I think to truly understand how winning such lawsuits will affect consumers (and merchants), it depends on how Visa explains it, "said Allen Walsh." They may argue that their transactions with merchants and competitors are beneficial to cardholders, and the case will largely depend on the persuasiveness of these arguments
How does Visa explain
Visa argues that it is "just one of many competitors" in the growing debit card industry and claims that the lawsuit is "baseless".
Visa's General Counsel Julie Rottenberg said in a statement, "When businesses and consumers choose Visa, it's because of our secure and reliable network, world-class fraud protection, and the value we offer
Lotte Berg stated that the lawsuit "ignores the fact that Visa is just one of the many growing competitors in the debit card field, with new entrants also thriving.
The lawsuit submitted by the Department of Justice on Tuesday did not require Visa to take specific remedial measures. However, regulatory agencies are seeking a ban to halt certain pricing and contract rules.
The indictment from the Department of Justice alleges that Visa used agreements with suppliers to force other payment processors to "not reach the scale required to compete with Visa. Law enforcement agencies have stated that Visa requires merchants and their financial institutions to make "multiple commitments", forcing them to use Visa in most card transactions, otherwise they will face higher fees.
John Donenberg, Deputy Director of the White House National Economic Council, did not comment on the lawsuit, but stated that the Biden administration has "made it clear that the US economy will only thrive if there is genuine competition.
The current government has also taken action against credit card late fees and bank overdraft fees, and will continue to work hard to combat other unfair garbage fees in daily transactions, "said Donaghberg.
CandyLake.com 系信息发布平台,仅提供信息存储空间服务。
声明:该文观点仅代表作者本人,本文不代表CandyLake.com立场,且不构成建议,请谨慎对待。
声明:该文观点仅代表作者本人,本文不代表CandyLake.com立场,且不构成建议,请谨慎对待。
猜你喜欢
- Hong Kong McDonald's: Affected products and ingredients are only available in the United States and have no involvement in Hong Kong
- How do the tax policies of both parties in the United States affect the stock market?
- Beware of the US election triggering market volatility! BlackRock: This risk is underestimated
- The US Treasury Department is reportedly considering investigating the decline of mainstream cryptocurrency Tether, a stablecoin giant
- The US economy grew slower than expected in the third quarter, and the market generally expects a 25 basis point interest rate cut next month
- How does Wall Street prepare for the US election? Hold cash and wait outside!
- Boeing US factory workers end strike through labor contract in union vote
- How will the US presidential election affect RMB assets as offshore RMB falls by over 900 points per day? Short term RMB may come under pressure
- Harris admits defeat in speech, leaving only final suspense in US election: ownership of House of Representatives
- Since Trump won the US election, hedge funds that insist on shorting Tesla are reported to have lost over $5 billion
-
自美国大选结果出炉、美国前总统特朗普宣布胜选以来,作为其本次竞选的“大金主”、特斯拉首席执行官埃隆·马斯克也赢麻了。 截至上周五美股收盘,特斯拉股价单日暴涨8.19%,总市值也重新站稳1万亿美元关口 ...
- chpuu
- 前天 10:56
- 支持
- 反对
- 回复
- 收藏
-
本报讯 (记者李豪悦)11月12日,腾讯音乐娱乐集团(以下简称“腾讯音乐”)宣布其截至2024年9月30日止第三季度的未经审计财务业绩。 2024年第三季度,腾讯音乐娱乐集团业绩表现稳健,总收入为70.2亿元,同 ...
- 覃志辉
- 昨天 20:07
- 支持
- 反对
- 回复
- 收藏
-
波音公司当地时间11月11日表示,该公司负责商用飞机品质的高级副总裁伊丽莎白·伦德(Elizabeth Lund)将于12月退休。伦德在波音公司工作了33年,在1月5日阿拉斯加航空公司一架新的737 MAX 9飞机在空中舱门脱落 ...
- charles1121
- 昨天 13:15
- 支持
- 反对
- 回复
- 收藏
-
近日,福特纵横户外主题乐园于“孔孟之乡、运河之都”——中国济宁正式揭牌。该公园是继福特在北美成功打造了六座“Bronco Nation”福特烈马公园后,全球第七座、北美以外唯一、也是中国首座户外主题乐园。 ...
- fly520
- 前天 13:27
- 支持
- 反对
- 回复
- 收藏